I don't really know if I like the book. I really don't like Holden at all, he seems like a big jerk. He kind of redeems himself at the end, but not really. He only seems to care for children and the innocence of childhood, and as much as I understand this it seems kind of creepy, also did anyone notice what happens when he takes his hat off and on???
Geoff!!! I don't think he's creepy at all! I think that he finds joy in childhood because those were where his best memories came from. Allie was still alive, and Holden was the happiest he may ever be. I noticed that when ever he was really depressed or upset he would put his hat on. I didn't notice a pattern when he took it off though... :)
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Hannah, his love of children isn't creepy. Children just remind him of his own childhood when he was happy, and as such he likes to be around them. I'm not sure what his hat was meaning. I found a few notes saying that it is of significance because he wears it pointing to the back like a baseball catcher might wear it, and that shows that he is trying to be "the catcher in the rye." Other than that I'm not sure.
ReplyDeleteI don't think he was creepy necessarily, but a lot of things bothered me. I wanted him to care about things or commit or apply himself and I was always disappointed when he didn't. And no, I never understood the hat thing!
ReplyDeletei like that he is kind of an asshole. It is a refreshing change of pace from the typical protagonist with a good heart, a clean mind, and a stereotypically normal/clean life. Holen is not nice, has a more realistic set of morals for a depressed and non conforming teen. In real life, it would probably hate him, but he is interesting to read about
ReplyDeletewell this is alittle late because we've long since finished catcher in the rye but thats exactly what I thought about the hat thing too! and towards the end i did kinda think that Holden seemed to get a little weirder than usual but i think thats just kinda how the ending is supposed to be, the reader is supposed to be really confused.
ReplyDelete"ur a tool" from Jason
ReplyDelete